I would qualify this as a major spoiler for season 3, so read on at your own risk.
Gee, well, I don’t have much to tell, other than the fact that in the first three minutes one of the lead heroes is going to bust a cap off at one of the other lead heroes. And oh yeah, the guy she pulls the trigger on just might be the guy she’s playing tonsil hockey with in real life. She also tells him (on cam), “I always loved you.” Whaaa?! Figured it out? I know you have, so discuss in the comments below! Oh, and even more shocking? We’re gonna see Claire-bear with dark hair and this also involves a shift in time. So very Lostalicious, no?
Claire shoots Peter? And tells him she loves him!?!
Theories? Here’s one…
Future Peter and Claire come to the past for opposite purposes, this Peter, who is evil, plots to kill his brother Nathan. Claire, on the other hand, is trying to save her father’s life. Claire contacts Nathan before the press conference and warns him what’s gonna happen, and he wears a vest as protection. After Peter shoots Nathan and he walks off, Claire confronts him, and after some dialogue shoots at him.
Source: ( by Kristin), Jay
What do you think?
{ 66 comments… read them below or add one }
1st 3 minutes means the 1st 3 minutes of Volume 3? If thats what it is, it would be great! Claire with dark hair means future Claire
. I think this theory would work much better with the fans than the previous theory about Future Peter walking out to confront the shooter. I hope this theory comes true, if it does, Volume 3 will be soooooo exciting and interesting….
That all just happens in just three minutes!? Wow, they are not holding anything back this season. If what you said is true then we are in for one hell of a show!
so peter gets shot in the first 3 minutes! and then Sylar kills one of the main hereos in the 1st couple of episodes? ‘Villains’ is going to be awesome!
also, i hope it is future peter thatgets shot so that the one in the present could still be killed by Sylar so that he can take his power and then kill the 12 villains that escape from the company and take their powers from them for the company.
what do you think?
…What can I say…?
This is awesome!!!!
I can’t wait for volume 3….
Man…I am so excited…
question: you say that future claire comes from the future with opposite intentions to peter, so clearly they wont time travel together, does this mean that future hiro brings claire back, because i also read somewhere that we would see the return of future hiro?
Rowan, if anything, it should Sylar is going to kill one of our future characters and that will have a double meaning. Sylar will have killed a main character but not in the way we know and if he gets future peter, they will face off with the same power and if he gets future claire, than he will be unstoppable.
But yeah. Volume three will be better than 1 and 2, no doubts about it.
read this yesterday and if it is true, cant wait. i heard kristin at Eonline is pretty reliable, she was the one who posted the spoiler. the theory could work and it is probably the one that makes the most sense and is the most exciting. but even if future claire shoots future peter, that isnt going to stop him or anything, i mean by that time he probably would have a lot of powers to stop a bullet from hitting him.
Maybe Claire chases after the person that shot Nathan and then shoots that person. Then that person is revealed to be Peter
You know the ClairexPeter fans are going to go nuts. But this does sound intruiging. Especially seeing future Hiro. I wonder if we get to go back to the future that has now been changed since they saved the cheerleader and destroyed the virus. We might just hear about it though.
As I’ve said before, things may not be what they seem.
OK that is weird, she is in love of her own uncle o.O… ok, thats weird really, how would Nathan react on this, everyone loves Peter, the word “I love you” is in fact Peter’s weakness, have you figure it that out, besides Nathan who else has said Peter “I love you”… any suggestions, because I never heard nor Simone or Caitlin tell him that word, now besides Nathan, now is Claire’s turn… oh I remember now who else has said to Peter “I love you”, Simones dad, Charles Devaux, well, many suggest “I love you” is a powerful thought.
Making Peter and Claire have this kind of relation, would mean that Nathan isnt his brother then, who knows, what a love triangle this three make, how cute… I love this three characters/actors, the only one left would be HRG so it could be a love square.
nobody said anything about being “in love”….
but i dunno. this is making 0 sense… will probably bel ess infuriating once they air it i suppose
Lol what’s with the “I love you thing…”
“in the end all that really matters is Love”- Charles Devaux
i don’t understand how claire can love her uncle?? but that would be kinda cool!
u guys aren’t makin any sense. how, when, what was claire in love wit peter. has that ever come up in the show. im just really confused. when somebody said claire will go after the shooter and shoot him, does that mean future claire b/c how will present claire get to wherever it is in time and how would she know about it?
that’s nonsense! Claire didn’t have time-traveling abilities like hiro & peter. I didn’t believe peter shot nathan. I bet it’s claire’s mom shot her dad. Don’t believe that bitch’s lies! She says I love u, she refer 2 nathan. Peter went back in time & trys 2 her. She did it 4 the company & they got claire.
I don’t find any reason for Claire’s real mum to kill NAthan? Out of what reason? Love? No way! Revenge? Maybe but no, if she wanna do it she could have done it in Season 1 or 2 why now?
So maybe 2 guesses:
Company hired some assasin to kill Nathan, to seal him from revealing the truth about the superbeings living among the society.
2nd guess:
Like what everyone said, Peter came back from future to kill Nathan or rather stop him from igniting the spark to an dark alternate future for both the normal being and the superbeings.
Things aside, we all know that Claire’s mum will make an appearence in this Season. Will she become the food for Slyar’s hunger? Will she reunited with Claire? Has she joined “The Company” ? Will she be considered the villian or the hero?
Conclusion: We’ll see ^^
Something I forgot about Peter and Nathan now that I mention them on my past comment, why would Peter shoot him, he doesnt whant him to die, he has said that, like in 1×23 “I cant let you die” and 2×08 when he takes him to the hospital “KEEP HIM ALIVE OK, DO WHAT EVER IT TAKE, DO YOU UNDERSTAND ME”, soo, I cant accept him killing his brother, Nathan didnt want the bomb to happen even if it was inevitable for him, and I dont think Meredith would do something like that neither, neither Claire, I dont trust Meredith, when Nathan left the money to her in the episode “RUN”, Meredith said that half of the money was for her, but It was only the 25% of it, she doesnt care for her anylonger, and Claire didnt want it, lets see how the reunion of the happy family turns up…
My guess, about Nathan, again, hope he is given wind abilities, he needs action, not only drama and politics, the characters that have give us enought action secuences are Peter, Hiro, Nikki, Matt recently, HRG, just hope the writers stop giving him hell of much credit, even in the grapich novels, Adam, Elle and Sylar, Claire has done much, and hope she continues delivering much, her dad takes more credit these days, Mohinder, well he is a scientist but at least his plot is well… hope se see Meredith fighting a Villian, if a water caster ever appears and she battles him that would be awsome, with her ability she can give a great fight, just like Elle, but instead of lightning, fire… ^-^… whish that in the grapich novels rise some ideas about the series characters besides HRG…
Finally, OK, now two of the characters we consider the mayor ones are going to die in the first 2 episodes, one killed by Claire in the firts 3 minutes as the spoiler says, and the one about Sylar opening the head of the character whe consider the shows star… any comments abou that, soo that means Peter may die twice of the time he has died, how many times Peter has died, five I think… Future Peter killed by Claire if he is Nathan’s shooter, and present Peter killed by Sylar, remember in the Jules Trailer of season 3 Peter is seen in a pool of blood…
About money Nathan give to Meredith, I pass, 25% for Claire when Meredith told her 50% was for her when she rejects it, soo Meredith would take 75% of it, but at the end she has all the money for her…
my guess’s wesly is peter’s clone like superboy & scarlet spider. The company used peter’s blood 2 created him when peter’s in the company. Remember 4 months later epoide? Nathan was looking a high school picture of peter. Wes looks like him in peter’s teen year & he peeps claire’s window. Peter’s mermories restores in his head. Another 3 years,he’ll might looks like peter. Claire’s dating peter’s clone,wesly in the future. That’s creepy!
my another guess’s simone’s nathan’s shooter. The company brings her back from the dead w/ peter’s blood when he held captive in the company. Rememer the begining of “parasites” epoisde, the company kept her corpse? She did it & they injected her the virus. She have 2 kill peter’s brother & 2 get a vaccine. Peter finds out who she was. She shots him. Claire saves him from death. He goes back in time 2 convice simone like wolvine & jean greg in x-men 3.
Anyone doubt the possibilities of Peter’s duplicates becoming evil and thus went back in time to kill Nathan? Imagine future Peter met someone with Duplicating ability that is able to duplicate 100% of oneself and everything. IMagine that! 50 Peter running around!!! OMG!
Lol.Simone sucks.
I hope she`ll never ever return back.Lol.
Hi Matt…
I think you should read Heroes Graphic Novels.
From now onwards,Chapter 81 and the latest novels act as spoiler.
If you go on youtube the trailer shows matt parkman dead on a chair it also show angela petrelli working with sylar going to see noah bennet. Series 3 will be sooo good r cant wait. Hope ali larter doesnt die she is my fav character.
The Claire and Peter shippers will be pleased. Me, not so much. Oh well.
As long as it’s future Peter and not current Peter that gets shot.
Anyone considered that maybe future Peter isn’t evil, and he just shot Nathan because telling the world about heroes turned out badly and he had to prevent it? But Claire of course still wants to defend daddy.
Just a thought.
I’m saying Simone might will be back as a villian like Ali larter’s character. She might have abilities, too. Like global warming abilities like storm from x-men or animal-shifting abilities, I don’t known. Maybe she’s nathan’s shooter. That’s all i saying!
okay… i feel weird about this whole ‘ i love you’ thing. she means it in a strictly familial way, right? or are they gonna have some soap opera type twist where suddenly, oh no, the aren’t related? no no no no, they won’t try to get them together, they couldn’t. besides the fact that (for now at least) they’re RELATED, she’s also like half his age. and has a boyfriend.
why not put a hundreds of future petrelli and nakamuras? or thousands billions just kidding
is there any rules bout this space bending thing? some way points..you know what im saying?like they all met each other and sez im hiro from 5:30, im hiro from 5:31IM THE REAL HERO AT 5:30
if there was plz enlighten me TNX
if the interval is lke spilt second or minitue then it would be possible. Imagine u talking to the next second of u. He will disappear since time has pass that second.
*would’nt
So they just HAD to find a way to allow Hayden and Milo to bring their offscreen relationship onscreen, huh? *sigh*
i think dat theory makes sense but i think it will all be a misunderstanding.future claire thinks future peter wanted to kill nathan but actually peter wanted to discover the identity of nathan’s shooter who might be donna.(appears in graphic novels)
she can shoot using any gun from long distances,with a sniper she can do anything.well this is just my theory.
why does peter need a gun to kill somebody. what about if clair shoots her father?
I think that future Claire killed Nathan. Maybe when Nathan spilled the truth, some X-Men chain reaction happened, and people started hating on mutants. So blah blah blah… bad shit starts happening. Claire goes to past to kill Nathan, because she wants a better future and Peter goes to stop her, because Nathan is his brother. The “I love you” sentence would make sense, because I’m sure Claire loved her bio-dad but she feels like he has to be silenced or else… There are some gaps in the story and what-not, but we shouldn’t assume that Claire isn’t capable of doing something “bad.”
I doubt it ws claire because the person just was’nt the right body type to be claire. And to be honest it looked like a man. I’m just guessing though from what I have seen. I do hope it was someone such as peter or nathans dad or somthing. Or possibly Noah .. as he didnt want the company exsposed by claire etc…. whatever It’s gonna rock whatever happens!
the bloke at the back who turned and walks away looks like peter but dosen’t mean that he or who ever it is shot him. i’d guess its HRG given he’s back working for the company but if there is some future angle i’d be dissapointed if it’s peter who could rip someone apart thinking about them (the door) used a gun to kill someone. claire seems to have a ruthless streek in her and could see her useing the end’s to justify the means logic. but then it probabley wouldn’t be any fun if you could guess it. ahhh why does augest always have to get in the way of september ahhhhhhhhh
me again………… what if clair travels back in time to give her father some blood and peter travels back in time to find who shot his brother?
I think Claire always got some crush with Peter, their chemistry speaks thousand words, lol.
claire could be the one who shot nathan she has already proven shes no angel i.e. the car “accedent” of season 1
I really dont think that she means shes in love with him…family members say i love u to eachother all the tym…it obviously wasnt refering to romantic feelings
It may work, or it may get to deep and loose viewers like the x files did.
I hope that doesn’t happen…
I think the i love you, was the family love towards him because i am very sure that tim kring doesn’t want to promote incest, and it would make sense because out her real family she is most likely to be the closest to him because he saved her life.
I dont think that future claire shot nathan because at one stage she wanted to tell her secret to expose the company, i think that it would be peter most likely because he is easy to walk over and easy to convince that someone is evil or if he do something the world will be a better place.
the only thing i am confused about is how did claire get back to the past???
Listen, I have read up on this, and heres the deal. Peter is not evil, future claire is. Claire, being indestructible, has to grow up, without growing old, and watch all her friends and familly die around her. This drives her to do evil stuff, and leads to the attempted shooting of peter. He does not actually get shot, he freezes time and moves out of the way, but yea, claire takes a turn for the worse.
i would love a claire/peter storyline. Milo and Hayden have electrifyign chemistry. I saw that on the first episodes when he saved the cheerleader and she saved him by pulling the class out of his head. Milo and Hayden are dating and really do have chemistry so I can’t think of a reason why the writers wouldn’t want to use that for a story arc. I mean I’m not comfortable with them beign in a love and related, so maybe another possible storyline would be nathan and peter aren’t really brothers or claire isnt really nathans daughter. I would love it. but then again this is my personal opinion.
oh yes! I’d love to see Peter/Claire together!
But I bet that’s gonna turn out like “I’ve always loved you… uncle Peter, but gotta kill you, bye”
Damn, and they got some of us excited for a minute!
OK, can we stop going doolally about this “I love you” thing? The Petrelli’s are definitely brothers, Claire is definitely Nathan’s biological daughter… She MUST mean she loves her Uncle Peter in a strictly familial context. Right? In the same way that Peter and Nathan expressed their BROTHERLY love for each other at the end of season 1. Remember? Or did y’all read too much into THAT as well? Wot a twisted bunch y’all are…
Now, to get to the real point… The Attempted Assassination of Nathan Petrelli. Future Peter and Future Claire being around for the first few minutes of the first episode does point towards it being one of them (particularly Peter), but hold on: are they definitely in the present day? (Do the scenes take place now, or in the future?) If they ARE in the present, then Peter may well be the one who pulled the trigger.
But then ask yourself this: with all of his power, (ie ability to freeze time, teleport, invisibility, etc) – and especially with his Future Self having more control and mastery over his numerous abilities, why would he use a gun, or risk being seen/ caught… or even NEED to shoot his brother? He could have stopped time and either killed Nathan or spoken to him/ teleported him elsewhere, tell him not to reveal anything – all before anyone knew what was happening.
You’ve seen Peter’s modus operandi. Don’t you think it a bit odd that the shooter was seen leaving (by Matt) when he could have turned invisible at least – or remained unseen the whole time? Think of season two, ‘Five Years Gone’, when he rescued Future Hiro and Ando from Future Matt using the above three powers in quick succession.
Still think Peter’s the shooter?
Also, after Nathan was shot, when it was televised, she was on the phone to someone (the shooter? Or the person that set up the hit?) saying that it had to be done, it was necessary. If FuturePeter is busy getting shot by FutureClaire he’s not going to be phoning his old dear, now, is he?
Now consider this.
Have you ever wondered what the story really was surrounding Arthur Petrelli, father to Nathan and Peter? I mean, he’s been mentioned a lot, and only seen VAGUELY in a photo. Apparently he committed suicide… Or did he? Correct me if I’m wrong, but I don’t remember there even being talk of a funeral for him. What was his power?
If someone was going to kill either one of Angela Petrelli’s beloved sons – and she didn’t seem too distressed at the news, even though she can be a cold woman – and speak to her about it afterwards, it makes more sense to me that it’ would more likely be her presumed-dead husband than her youngest offspring from the future (interesting family, huh?).
And I understand that Artur Petrelli will be making an appearance this season? (Don’t know if that is inthe present or in flashbacks, or during a time travel trip to the past, etc). But hmmm… I reckon my suspicions about Arthur Petrelli faking his death (or at least not being as dead as we thought he was) might hold something.
Let me know what y’all think.
I totally agree with but…. Peter is definetly the one who shoots Nathan!
My bad. Just done some research (checked out spoilers, video footage, season 3 trailers, etc)… and I have to admit in shocked disbelief that Petey is the gunman!
If you ask me, I still say that stopping time (as one option) and talking his brother out of selling out all evolved humans would have been more characteristic of Peter. What happened to this future version of Peter, I wonder, to make him so ready to murder his older sibling, who he used to love and respect so much? I guess the future that Nathan unwittingly brought about must have been a VERY dark place indeed.
(With that said, I would rather watch an attempted assassination and escape than a brother-to-brother pep-talk! )
So, I stand corrected… Still think it should have been the father, though.
Hey, wot d’ya think? End of season 1, Nathan gets toasted to a crisp. End of season 2, Nathan gets shot.
How is Nathan going to die at the end of this season – and how will he miraculously survive/ get resurrected/ be healed etc? Answers on a postcard please.
Maybe future Peter is somehow “corrupted” . In “5 Years Gone” Peter seems a little more badass in the scene when he and future Hiro go rescue the other Hiro instead of passing trough the guards he decides to fight against them